Would you rather

I had a ‘hole in one’ for a par after dunking my first left in the lake, does that count as a ‘hole in one’?

Either way, I’d definitely go for the two eagles, especially if I could choose when I had them!

I’ll take the hole in one...on the 600 yd yard monster that has been giving me so much trouble over the past 20 years. It would help ease some of the pain.

Two eagles, as long as you could choose when, that would be useful!

P.S. I had a ‘hole in one’ for a par after dunking my first in the lake left - does that count?

I've 2 hole in ones (or is it holes in one) and I've holed out from the fairway for an eagle as well. One is certainly more special as it requires the purchase of drinks and the other is no different on the scorecard than if you hit a par 5 in two and made the putt. But I'd still take an ace over a hole out for eagle any day of the week. Now if you want to talk an ace on a drivable par 4 or a 2nd shot hole out on a par 5 for an albatross...…………………...

i'd take the hole outs for sure.

getting one hole in one in your lifetime is a cool achievement, but a lot of total duffers still get 'em. it's often a janky skull that works out in your favor

if you're holing out from the fairway twice a year, it's clearly more than luck.

Holing out for eagle twice a year from the fairway, for life!

Never had the ace, but did hole out twice (back to back) rounds. Will be happy to just keep playing for the rest of my life. As you get older your appreciation for the game gets deeper!

Hole out for Eagles for sure.

Just let me have the hole in one. Eagles are great and one might say even more difficult, but the staying power of a hole in one is undeniable

Eagles. An occasional Double Eagle even better.

Eagles for sure. While I haven't a hole in one yet.
I would take the extra 2 under and extra skin every year.

Just for a different perspective, I'd go for the hole in one - you don't get a Titleist Hole in One tag for any other eagle!
JT

I’ve already had the aces, so I would take the eagles.

Even though I’m not from Philly: “Fly Eagles Fly”

The eagles are an easy choice since they would happen multiple times per year. I've holed out for eagle quite a few times including one from 165-ish yards, and I have one hole in one. The hole in one is the one I remember vividly

Eagles without a doubt!

Eagles, eagles and more eagles to be sure. I am still searching for the elusive ace but would trade for the eagles all day long.

I would love to get 2 eagles a year. Imagine it happening in your member guest or your last round of the year and you haven't had any. What a thrill that would be. A hole in one is nice but it only lasts so long and its just once. Ill take the eagles for lifetime!

I haven't gotten the hole in one, but would go with the twice per year eagles for ever!